Running with a comment from Carly in the last post, I thought it would be a good time to address the White House Christmas card scandal.
Carly said:
“…I saw nothing wrong with Bush sending out “Holiday” cards that didn’t use the word Christmas specifically. Political correctness can go too far on both sides of the holiday issue. Whatever happend to social politeness?”
Bush is sending 1.4 million cards to his “closest friends,” as the Washington Post article states, and the message in the card is “Happy Holidays,” not “Merry Christmas.”
I suspect that there is a good percentage of that 1.4 million people who Bush has never even seen before, much less met. They probably donated to his campaign, but I doubt that Bush really considers them his “closest friends.” (Do you know anyone with 1.4 million close friends?)
I also suspect that there could be a fraction of that 1.4 million who may not necessarily celebrate Christmas, even if the Christian Right makes up a strong percentage of Bush’s financial supporters.
If you’re sending cards to those whom you don’t know, it’s safer to wish “Happy Holidays” and be all-inclusive. I agree that there’s nothing wrong with sending a card with that message. Bush’s problem is that he has tried to define himself, in part, by his religious convictions. So I can see why, to some, it seem might seem a little two-faced of him to abandon the word “Christmas.” I don’t agree with that point of view, but I can understand why some of them are mildly upset about it.
A while back, I worked a part-time job in a Thomas Kinkade art gallery. Kinkade, for those who have never heard of him, is an artist who is known for his luminist style, which means that he paints images that have a sense of light in them and that take on a “glow” when lights are dimmed. (It’s not glow-in-the-dark paint…it’s actually a trick of the eye through the contrasts from darks to warm amber colors, but that’s beside the point.) In any case, Kinkade always includes the words “John 3:16″ next to his signature as a testament of his own faith.
Kinkade is blessed with a brilliant marketing team who found ways to put his images on virtually everything…from coffee mugs to coasters to tapestries to nightlights.
And Christmas cards!
Except that a few years ago, Kinkade started issuing “Happy Holidays” Christmas cards. This upset some of the customers, who felt that Kinkade was cowtowing to secular pressure. In that case, I agreed with them, because it was Christmas-themed images, homes with giant Christmas trees and decorated with Yuletide glee, that adorned the front of the card. Don’t give me a Christmas image and wish me “Happy Holidays.” If you’re going to be “bold” enough to print a Christmas-themed image on the front, you might as well wish whoever receives it a “Merry Christmas.” You’re not fooling anyone with the generic wish on the inside.
This year’s White House Christmas card doesn’t feature a Christmas-themed image on the front. In fact, it features a snow-covered scene of the South Portico of the White House. You see the American flag. You don’t see a Christmas tree. There’s no subtle message of Christmas on the front that is then downplayed with a “Happy Holidays” message on the inside.
But that doesn’t stop Christmas enthusiasts from losing the happiness of the season:
“This clearly demonstrates that the Bush administration has suffered a loss of will and that they have capitulated to the worst elements in our culture,” said William Donohue, president of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights.
The worst elements of our culture?
Who’s he talking about? People who are asking others to be tolerant? They’re the worst elements of our culture? I’m a Christian, but if he thinks they’re the worst elements of our culture, I don’t want to know who he thinks the best elements would be.
I do think it’s a shame that people who celebrate Christmas are being made to feel ashamed to do so freely. If we really have religious freedom in this country, we should all be able to celebrate whatever holiday we want without being judged by our decision. I don’t like this “PC” culture that is being forced upon us at every turn any more than anyone else. But there comes a point at which it isn’t about being politically-correct, so much as just having manners.
If you’re going to take the effort to extend your holiday wishes to others with a personal note in the mail, it seems only polite that you take the time to make sure that the person you’re wishing Merry Christmas to actually celebrates it. It’s that “social politeness” that Carly mentioned.
If you have a Christmas card list with 1.4 million names, that’s a tall order. In that case, if you’re not willing to narrow your list a bit, you’re a lot better off using the generic “Happy Holidays” wish. After all, one who celebrates Christmas and one who celebrates Hanukkah will get the same sentiment from someone who wishes them happiness on their holiday, even if the specific word isn’t there. All that is required of them is that they receive the message of goodwill in the spirit in which it is intended.
My list is about 25 names long, and I have made every effort to make sure that the people I send Christmas cards to do celebrate Christmas (or at least don’t mind receiving a card with that sentiment). Some years, I send out “Merry Christmas” cards. Some years, it’s “Happy Holidays.” And other years, it’s “Season’s Greetings.” With me, it depends more on the design of the card than on my responsibility to serve as a representative of some religion.
Most of the people on my list have sent me Christmas cards as well, so I know that whether they go overboard in celebrating Christmas themselves, they at least willingly participate in this great annual charity event for the postal service and thereby attempt to spread cheer this time of year.
I don’t send Christmas cards to people who I know don’t celebrate Christmas. Does that make me a bad person? Am I somehow less of a Christian for not ministering through a Christmas card? Am I suddenly part of the “worst elements of our culture?”
I don’t think so.
If the Christmas season is supposed to be one of love for your fellow man, why would I wait until that time of year to attack someone else’s beliefs? That doesn’t sound all that Christian-like to me.
Whatever holiday you choose to celebrate, I hope yours is a great one.