Fair and Balanced
You know all of those rabid Clinton supporters who have been whining about how unfair the coverage of their candidate has been? A just-released study that scrutinized the coverage paints a quite different story.
“…Sen. Hillary Clinton did not get tougher press coverage than Sen. Barack Obama when it came to the main themes about their character, history, leadership qualities and overall appeal.
In fact, it was just the opposite starting after Clinton criticized the media for being too soft on Obama.”
Clinton’s supporters have also been trying to encourage everyone to boycott MSNBC, the cable network they feel has been most unfair to their candidate.
Wrong again, according to the study:
“For example, 69% of the assertions about Obama on Fox News Channel were positive, versus 54% for Clinton. And both far outdistanced Sen. John McCain, with only 45%.
On CNN, Clinton was the clear winner, with 70% positives versus 59% for Obama and 49% for McCain.
The most even-handed, at least toward the Democrats, was MSNBC, the researchers concluded, with 72% positives for Clinton and 70% for Obama (McCain got 53%).”
It isn’t clear from the report exactly what constitutes a “positive assertion” versus a “negative assertion.” It is most likely that this refers to stories like Rev. Jeremiah Wright’s controversial comments, which — I’m just guessing here — would go in the “negative” column for Obama. It’s also not necessarily realistic to say that these networks are biased towards one side or the other; it’s possible to cover the news of the day, including whatever the controversy du jour happens to be, present fair coverage, and still have the overall tone of the story fall into either the “positive” or “negative” side.
Still, it’s quite interesting that Clinton, who has beaten her “experience” down out throats much the way John Kerry touted his Purple Hearts, and who has complained about being so mistreated by the press (when she wasn’t), managed to get more negative coverage going for her opponent, and still finds herself in such a desperate fight for the nomination she’s not likely to get anyway.
And it also appears to demonstrate that Obama, who got a rougher ride after the media allowed itself to be influenced by the senator from New York’s complaints, has still survived the added scrutiny.
Clinton supporters who have had a hand in this should be ashamed of themselves. And they should rethink their temper-tantrum threats to vote for McCain out of spite if Hillary. The only person making Hillary the underdog is Hillary.
The lesson for the media here, it appears, is to stop listening to candidates who say, “You’re nicer to the other guy.” The lesson for the politically-charged media haters is, perhaps, “Look a little more closely before you complain.”













I don’t have any stats to back this up — this is just my opinion based on observation — but it’s really hard to believe that MSNBC was in any way “even-handed” toward Clinton and Obama. Having watched enough Hardball and *especially* Countdown it’s been clear they have been backing Obama for months now.
The question is, Jeff, are shows like “Hardball” or “Countdown” really legitimate news or are they more commentary and opinion. If, as I suspect, they are ruled in the latter category, then they shouldn’t be included in such a study at all.
The challenge is getting the viewing public to realize that there’s a big difference between legit news and commentary.
Good point. I absolutely agree with you that there’s a difference between “hard news” and commentary. I would also add, on a personal note, that I am not in the group that is obsessed with media bias. Really. That’s not where I was going with that, in case anyone thinks I was.
I should have made it clear that I was referring to the overall presentation of political information by MSNBC. I do NOT detect a pro-Obama bias during their regular news updates, during the daytime hours of coverage or when I have watched the NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams (which I rarely watch). The bias that I see is pretty much confined to “Hardball” and, to a greater extent, “Countdown.”
They are, of course, free to do what they do and viewers who aren’t happy are free to change the channel. The remote control is the best weapon against something you don’t want to see on TV, no matter what it is.
Leave your response!
About Me
Patrick is a television producer, writer, Mac lover, and Christian, though not necessarily in that order. He has a natural dislike of double standards and poor grammar.
Upcoming Posts
Polls
My Twitterstream
1 day ago from Patrick's Place
2 days ago from web
2 days ago from TweetDeck
2 days ago from TweetDeck
3 days ago from web
Browse By Popular Topics
Television Saturday Six Politics Sunday Seven Humor Blogging Religion News & Media Memes Personal Health Celebrities CBS Writing & Publishing Internet Mind Boggling Customer Service Children Out There Advertising Crime Holidays Double Standards Discrimination NBC Memorial Election 2008 YouTube Pet Peeves Government Technology Hot-Button Issues Diet Arch-a-thon God-time AOL Game Shows Language Homosexuality Racism Best Of Grammar Consumer Friends Patrick's Place Poll Schools Economy Dogs Speaking Out Photography Movies Spam Weather War in Iraq Books Monday's Morals ABC WordPress Decency Cable Religion Run Amok Comments Animals Pets Twitter Food & Drink The Price is Right Environment Military Money Reality Shows Breaking News Tuesday Two Anxiety & Depression 9/11 Telephone Facebook Conspiracy Theories Marriage Mac Election 2004 iPhone Random 10 Devotions Debt Newspapers Richmond Hurricanes Election Authors Fiction Patriotism Abortion 100 Days of Integrity Fox Blogger Terrorism CNN Relationships TV Land Charleston Drugs Health Care Charity Sports Soap Operas Music Upfronts Horror Fiction Hurricane Katrina Alcohol Photo Challenge Driving Porn GSN Digital Television Bob Barker Walter Cronkite Fox News War on Christmas Turning 40 South Bay Earthquakes Maymont Star Trek Charleston 9 Citizen Journalism Patrick's 100 Year in Review Syndication Copyright The Andy Griffith Show Breastfeeding Zesto Election 2012 The CW Better Blogging Immigration MSNBC Cemetery Confederacy Death Penalty Vivi Awards HBO PBS
-- Powered by Category Cloud
Archives
Meta
Subscribe via Feedblitz
Recent Comments
Month’s Top Commenters
Tags
Local Blogs
The Credits
Copyright ©2004-2010 Patrick K. Phillips
All Rights Reserved.
Some images, videos and excerpts appear through Fair Use and are not intended as a challenge to copyright or ownership. The inclusion of videos from YouTube are provided as Fair Use and within the terms of YouTube's copyright policies, which specify that the party uploading the content and authorizing embedding in other sites either holds the copyright for that material or has obtained permission to do so. Certain images have been licensed through iStockphoto.com, Stockfresh.com and the Hemera Clip Art Collection.