Blogging

What’s This Trend of Killing Blog Comments Really About?

Every so often, I see another blogger announce to the masses why he has decided to shut down all comments from his blog.

When I scan through the article for the reason they’d come to such a decision, it almost always comes down to the same issue: there are too few comments these days compared to the “golden days of blogging” — whenever they were.

If really pressed for an answer, and since their readers can no longer leave comments, they aren’t pressed much, they will then add this fact to their justification of killing blog comments completely: “Since almost no one comments anymore, it’s not worth the effort involved.”

Well, wait a minute.

They just told me almost no one was commenting. They just told me the throngs of faithful commenters had all but migrated to Siberia.

So I immediately wonder: What effort?

How much work was it before those commenters moved on to other things to occupy their time? Wouldn’t that have been the time to not have comments, when the “work” involved had to be much greater because the volume of comments was higher?

Are we talking about the “effort” involved in responding to comments? If so, fewer comments would mean less effort.

So again, what’s the problem here?

If they said the problem involved some monumental amount of spam they receive, I might be a little better able to understand. For my blog, which has experienced significant growth over the past few years, the addition of plugins like Akismet and Livefyre pretty much wiped out about 99.5% of spam comments. So for me, there’s been almost no effort there at all.

But spam is rarely mentioned as the cause for the change.

I suspect the real reason comes down to pride. I’d love to publish posts that would immediately pull in dozens of comments. Eleven years ago, when this blog was housed on AOL’s blogging platform that was more of a closed community, I would often have posts with 30+ comments.

It was nice.

At the same time, it was work responding to comments that needed responses. But I didn’t mind because it was proof (in the days before Google Analytics could provide another form of proof) that people were actually coming here to read what little old me had to say.

Nowadays, I’m lucky to pull in a half-dozen comments to any single post. In a perfect world, I’d get more comments. But in a perfect world, I’d have more time to respond to more comments.

In this imperfect world, I don’t and I don’t.

If anything, it makes me appreciate the handful I do get rather than resent the “work” involved in reading and, where applicable, responding to them.

Do they think it looks bad to receive no comments? If they do, and that’s the real reason to kill comments altogether, I’d respect that decision. I won’t necessarily agree with it, since most of us know that social shares seem to be regarded as the new comments. But I’d at least respect it, if anyone would actually come right out and say so.

It just doesn’t make sense to me to hear someone complaining that it’s more work to keep track of fewer comments.

That math just doesn’t add up.

And I can’t help but think, as a blog owner, that I’d rather give that small handful of people who might want to give some input the chance to do so rather than just closing that door altogether.

I can’t help but wonder what kind of message we’re sending when we close comments. Isn’t that like saying to your readers, “I don’t care what you think”? It feels that way to me.

I think I’d rather run the risk of having no comments while giving a faithful reader a chance to still have his or her say in those moments that person wants to do so.

There are still valuable points of view and interesting ideas waiting to be heard.

Even once in a while.

3 Comments

  1. I had just been ranting about this very same topic, so I’m really glad to read this blog post. You basically said everything I did, sans potty mouth. I’ll be writing on this topic Monday, and will link to you here, so hopefully you get even more comments. 🙂

  2. How’s this for irony? I’m gonna leave a comment here…:-)

    I agree with you, it seems pointless to close comments sections down using the excuse that you don’t get many anyway…by shutting it down, you’re guaranteeing you never will get some! I’ve been able to control the spam on my blog pretty well and comments are cyclical, but I get a good number. Often it’s because a post of mine is hot right after I publish it, but it’s awesome when someone discovers an older post of mine and is interested enough to comment on it. I would hate to not have that interaction and feedback with my readers.

  3. I only get a few comments (other than spam or hate comments) once in a while, but when I do it makes my day and last week one post generated a discussion. When that happens I’m in heaven, not only does it validate my blog but shows that there are intelligent people who are reading it.

Leave a Response

We'd love to hear from you, but remember all comments must be respectful. We reserve the right to remove comments that do not follow our comment guidelines. Click here to review our comment policy.

Your name, as provided, will display on the website with any comment you leave. Your email address and your browser’s IP address does not display publicly and we do not share or sell your email address or IP address to anyone.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Patrick is a Christian with more than 28 years experience in professional writing, producing and marketing. His professional background also includes social media, reporting for broadcast television and the web, directing, videography and photography. He enjoys getting to know people over coffee and spending time with his dog.